Do Forbidden Acts Become OK If You Do Them Weirdly Enough?
Ever wanted to know the answer to some deep and challenging questions in halakhah (Jewish law)? Join R. Avi Killip interviewing R. Ethan Tucker with questions sent in by Yeshivat Hadar alumni and others on all sorts of details of Jewish law. This is a joint project between the Center for Jewish Law and Values and Jewish Public Media.
Want to submit a question to be answered in a future episode? Email [email protected].
In this episode: There is a concept in Jewish shabbat law called "shinui", "change". Certain acts when done in the usual way may be considered disobeying the laws of shabbat, while doing those same acts differently, with a shinui, may be fine. What lies behind this idea? When should shinui be used, and when should it not be used?